What Changed
- Empowerment under Article 13(10) of the 2026 ICC Rules for the ICC Court to appoint all tribunal members to prevent risks to award validity.
- Established mechanisms under ICC Rules to ensure arbitrations proceed despite party non-participation (affecting ~17% of total cases).
- Entry into force of updated ICC Arbitration Rules on 1 June 2026, clarifying disclosure obligations and removing mandatory Terms of Reference in standard proceedings.
Background
The phrase "New World Order" has historically been used to describe fundamental political or economic shifts, such as President Woodrow Wilson's vision following World War I for the League of Nations and an era of peace and prosperity. Today, the global environment is marked by an increasingly multipolar world, armed conflicts, competing regulatory frameworks, trade barriers, declining confidence in international alliances, and rapid technological change driven by artificial intelligence.
Throughout such periods of volatility, international trade and cross-border commercial ties play a vital role. While free trade alone cannot prevent conflicts, increased trade openness and interdependence can deter costly armed disputes, particularly those concerning valuable natural resources. Within this framework, the ICC International Court of Arbitration—founded in 1923 by entrepreneurs self-described as the "Merchants of Peace"—serves as an independent and impartial forum for resolving cross-border commercial and state disputes.
While the majority of parties in ICC arbitrations are private commercial entities or individuals, state involvement remains significant. In recent years, approximately one-quarter of all ICC cases involved states or state-owned enterprises (SOEs). Furthermore, state-to-SOE and SOE-to-SOE disputes represent a substantial portion of the caseload, addressing major economic infrastructure projects such as oil pipelines and potential copper mining arbitrations.
Institutional Safeguards and Rule Requirements
To safeguard the arbitral process and maintain confidence in outcomes, the ICC Court enforces specific rules and supervisory procedures:
1. Tribunal Constitution and Article 13(10)
Arbitration agreements may sometimes feature uneven terms, such as granting one party the sole right to nominate a single or presiding arbitrator, or requiring multiple respondents with conflicting interests to make a joint nomination. In line with the landmark French Cour de Cassation decision in Siemens v Dutco, Article 13(10) of the 2026 ICC Rules empowers the ICC Court to appoint each member of the arbitral tribunal if the party-agreed method of constitution poses a risk to the validity of the award. First adopted in 2021, this institutional power is exercised in exceptional circumstances to ensure party equality and protect the final award from enforcement challenges.
2. Addressing Non-Participating Parties
In recent years, nearly one in six ICC cases (approximately 17%) involved a non-participating party. In disputes governed by the Expedited Procedure Provisions, which typically involve lower-value claims, this rate rises to between 25% and 35%. To prevent defaulting parties from stalling proceedings, the ICC Rules establish four operational responses:
- The ICC Court appoints an arbitrator if a respondent fails to do so.
- If a respondent fails to file an Answer, the tribunal determines jurisdictional questions directly, unless referred by the Secretary General to the Court for a prima facie determination.
- The arbitration proceeds notwithstanding a party's refusal or failure to participate in any stage.
- Tribunals are empowered to proceed with scheduled hearings if a duly summoned party fails to appear without a valid excuse.
3. Mandatory Scrutiny of Draft Awards (Article 37(3))
Under Article 37(3) of the ICC Rules, no partial, final, or consent award may be rendered by an arbitral tribunal without prior scrutiny and approval by the ICC Court. The Court reviews draft awards to evaluate validity, enforceability, and compliance with mandatory law at the seat of arbitration. While most draft awards are approved with comments, roughly 10% are not initially approved, requiring tribunals to review a revised draft following the Court's feedback.
4. Updates in the 2026 ICC Arbitration Rules
Revised ICC Rules of Arbitration enter into force on 1 June 2026. Introduced by ICC Court President Claudia Salomon, key modifications include targeted enhancements to arbitrator disclosure obligations and the removal of mandatory Terms of Reference in standard proceedings to improve procedural speed and flexibility.
Practical Implications for Parties and Counsel
For businesses, state entities, and legal advisors navigating international contract negotiations and disputes, the ICC institutional framework offers several practical protections:
- Contractual Planning: Parties must review dispute resolution clauses to ensure nomination provisions do not create procedural imbalances that could trigger Court intervention under Article 13(10).
- Management of Defaulting Counterparties: The rules protect claimants against procedural blockades when a respondent refuses to appear or submit defense filings.
- Award Quality Control: Institutional scrutiny of draft awards reduces the risk of post-award annulment proceedings or set-aside applications in local enforcement courts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: How does Article 13(10) of the 2026 ICC Rules address unfair tribunal constitution clauses?
Answer: Article 13(10) permits the ICC Court to appoint every member of an arbitral tribunal if the appointment mechanism in the arbitration agreement risks invalidating the award, protecting equal treatment in accordance with principles established in Siemens v Dutco.
Q2: What occurs under ICC Rules when a respondent fails or refuses to participate in an arbitration?
Answer: The arbitration continues. The ICC Court will appoint an arbitrator on the respondent's behalf if required, jurisdictional challenges are handled by the tribunal (or prima facie by the Court if referred), and hearings proceed if a duly summoned party fails to attend without a valid excuse.
Q3: What is required during the ICC Court's award scrutiny process under Article 37(3)?
Answer: Every draft award must be scrutinised and approved by the ICC Court prior to issuance. The Court assesses enforceability and mandatory legal requirements at the place of arbitration. Approximately 10% of draft awards are not approved on initial review and require tribunal consideration of Court comments.
Q4: When do the revised ICC Arbitration Rules take effect, and what are key updates?
Answer: The updated ICC Rules enter into force on 1 June 2026. Key updates noted include enhanced arbitrator disclosure obligations and the removal of mandatory Terms of Reference in standard proceedings.
Who May Be Affected
Private businesses, state-owned enterprises, states, legal counsel, and arbitrators involved in cross-border trade and ICC arbitration.
Cross-Border Context
Applies to international trade, investment, and cross-border commercial disputes across multiple legal traditions involving private parties, states, and state-owned enterprises.
What to check next
- Official text of the revised ICC Arbitration Rules entering into force on 1 June 2026.
- ICC Court guidance materials regarding updated arbitrator disclosure obligations and the removal of mandatory Terms of Reference.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Consult the official text and obtain advice appropriate to your circumstances where needed.